Again my
question is… what is wrong with Indian media, especially the visual media? Why
these new generation visual media ‘prodigies’ are always exaggerating
anything that comes near their vicinity?
How can these ‘Goswamis’ become experts
on anything under the sun? Who on earth
has authorized these modern day
‘Sherlock Holmeses’ to authoritatively conduct and declare the verdict on
matters which are no way under their ‘jurisdiction’? Still as poor ‘viewers’ of these nonsense ‘cubs’ tolerance is the only option before us.
Isn’t?
Knowing about
ethics of journalism and adhering to its basic principles are some minimum
qualities that a journalist must possess.
The label of journalism doesn’t permit anyone to go overboard on any
individual and tarnish his/her personal
or professional image in the public. It
also doesn’t permit the intrusion into anyone’s privacy.
Coming to the case of Sunanda Pushkar’s
death, I expect our media to act with little more
responsibility. When debate sessions in
our news channels becomes battle fields of words, mission of these channels to identify the
real issue gets sidelined and only to increase their TRP rating becomes the
ultimate goal. I do not blame their
marketing strategy. However, what I am concerned is, should they play this
dirty game in someone’s expense?
Why do I say
this is, there are many anchors who conduct these debates with their pre-notion
on the subject. Let them have it. I am
not against it. But how can they force others to believe and agree to
their views? For example, when I express some opinion on
one subject that is just ‘MY’ opinion and need not necessary it must be the truth. If our debate anchors conduct their program
with this point in mind, they will be successful in extracting more information
from others in the debate that will ultimately bring out something good out of the show.
There are lot
of speculation going around on the cause of Sunanda Pushkar’ death. Everyone has
the liberty to assume things with their
own intelligence and have their own perspectives. However,
it is very pathetic to see the argument of some media people who are
trying to play junior Sherlock Holmeses and forcing the viewers to believe that
it is a murder case that has been surely carried out by her husband Shashi
Tharoor. When I first ‘saw’ the BREAKING NEWS on these TV channels saying SUNANDA PUSH
MURDERED: CONFIRMS DELHI POLICE, I thought the police must have got some solid
evidence that made them to come on this conclusion. However, my repeated
efforts to find out through these ‘channels’ , there was nothing ‘new’ I
could summarize from the new
revelations. At least these junior ‘Sherlock Holmeses ’ must have taken some
more pain to dig further deep into extract something solid that has made the
police to reach into this conclusion. Strangely, the police had nothing new to
reveal, except she died “UNNATURAL’ death and it was cause of POISONING!!!!! Arre baba, this
was something we are hearing from day one, there is nothing new. Can someone come forward and enlighten me if
‘unnatural death’ means it is only a murder?
Because our media people are making out it in that way. Then came the
photographs of her body which shows bruises and injection marks which these
medias showcase as the proof that
Sunanda was attacked by someone.
Followed by now infamous ‘INJURY
NO. 10” that could be the cause of the death!!!!!. I really surprised how these ‘over-reacting’
media people gets such false information and wasting hours of hours of time
just on arguments. When these same
people who have managed to capture a copy of the FIR all their arguments have got
bumped. In the FIR it has been stated
that the injurious found on Sunanda’s body are 12 hours to 4 days old and none
of these injuries are amount of her death.
There are
also other statements that have been made out by people like Nalini Singh and
Shobha De. One of the statements was Ms. Sunanda has revealed that she has some
serious illness and she is not going to survive for a long time. Other is
Shashi Tharoor is connected to some other ladies and he is not sincere to
Sunanda. How far it is true or false to be a matter that needs to be probed and
proved.
However, from
an ordinary thinking mind I can summarize the whole happenings in some other way
which will be more scientific and logical.
That
is……..Sunanda was very much suffering from some kind of mental depression.
There is a
possibility that she was suffering from narcissistic
personality disorder (NPD).
This condition must have developed from her attitude of over possessiveness
towards her husband. The way it has been told by her friends, she threatened
Shashi Tharoor and complained about his sincerity towards her. This claim leads
to believe that she was mentally depressed and could not stand to tolerate her
husband getting associated with any other woman other than herself.
Now coming to NPD, it is
said, people
who are diagnosed with a narcissistic personality disorder are characterized by exaggerated feelings of self-importance. They have a sense of
entitlement and demonstrate grandiosity in their beliefs and behavior. They
have a strong need for admiration, but lack feelings of empathy. It
further states that NPD is a Cluster B personality disorder in which
a person is excessively preoccupied with personal adequacy, power
prestige and vanity, mentally unable to see the destructive damage they are
causing to themselves and to others in the process.
I have made above
observations on the basis of the statements and arguments that I have heard and
read in the media and not on any medical ground. However, if the observation holds any water,
it is easy to reach on to a convincing conclusion of Sunanda’s death theory.
That is…. It was habitual
for her to get into argument with her husband on subject that are mainly connected
to some woman or women. There is no wonder even if she has threatened him by bringing
matters he has been infamously associated with -- matters such as IPL etc. One of the interesting part of the whole
episode is, no one, even her close relations, never never, never ever,
(courtesy Arnab) have pointed a finger at Shashi Tharoor accusing him of hurting her physically or
emotionally any point of time.
Initially there were lot
of arguments going on about the injuries
on her body and it was made out to be the result of an attack on her. Then the
Dubai connection and unknown people staying in the hotel with fake passports
etc. etc. However, when the FIR became a
public document through the ‘efforts’ of visual media, most of these claims had
to be shelved and now these media prodigies are looking for other ‘loopholes’ in
the inquiry, (FYI: A injury mark appears NOT only when a person gets attacked
by someone but it can also happen in other way around, I mean hitting somebody
can cause harm or injury to your own body too. As the injuries in Sunanda
Pushkar’s body seems to be minor ones, the chances of above possibility increases.).
From all the evidence that
has been revealed and are in the public domain suggest that it was a possible
case of suicide or a death due to overdose of drugs. The Delhi police claims it is an ‘unnatural
death’ and she has been ‘poisoned’.
However, there is no reason or evidence to believe till today that she
was poisoned by someone else. If at all poison was administered, it should have
be done by herself.
Let me conclude with a
report appeared in the Economic Times on January 21, 2014.
‘Autopsy report shows 27 tablets of
Alprax caused Sunanda Pushkar’s death’
Autopsy
findings in the death of Sunanda Pushkar are believed to have indicated that
she had died because of an overdose of a
prescription drug, Alprax, which may have made her slip into coma and perhaps
die in her sleep last Friday. Though there are over a dozen minor injury marks
on her hands and face, they are not related to her death, the doctors at AIIMS
are believed to have said in the autopsy report terming
the cause of death as "drug overdose".
Now the Delhi police have
two options. Either they must admit that the above autopsy report was the one
that they have received from doctors of AIIMS or they must come out and reveal
something that they were able to lay their hands on to believe it was a clear
case of murder. Whatever the truth is,
it is the responsibility of the Delhi to police to put a full stop to all speculations
and embarrassments.